
At the last City Council meeting, the council was supposed to vote to finally hire on HDR, Inc. (the nation’s preeminent transit planners, whose streetcar resume stretches across dozens of projects in development and whose streetcar chief, Charlie Hales, had a hand in Portland, Oregon’s wildly successful project) to commence a full-up study of the Fort Worth modern streetcar project. HDR would conduct a multi-phase design study that would answer all the remaining questions about the project: an exact alignment, operational details, construction and operation costs, economic and development impacts (to show how much development could accompany the streetcar line), etc. etc. etc. This final study would give the city all the information it needed to move forward with the project, or not, if it was determined to not be feasible.
We reported back in November that the city had selected a firm to handle the design duties – that firm was HDR. Yet HDR has not been officially hired on. The reasons why are becoming clear: certain councilmembers, wealthy individuals, and other influential parties are looking to sink the project before the study is even underway, for reasons of both petty political bickering and to help two of the wealthiest corporations in the United States.
HDR is to be hired using approximately $1.8 million dollars. Almost all of that money comes from the North Central Texas Council of Governments, which granted Fort Worth this money specifically to hire a consultant for this study. This money is already here, and waiting to be used. HDR knows they’re the firm, and are waiting for the green light.
At the last council meeting, when the vote to hire HDR came up, it got delayed until April 6th. This latest in a string of delays has caused strong frustration within the city, within the business and development communities, and within the citizens who are eager for progress on the streetcar project. It now appears to us that this delay is due to a variety of forces attempting to kill the project before the study is even underway.
There appears to be an effort underway now to stop the study from happening, and to raid the NCTCOG grant money and turn it over to at-grade improvements for the infamous Tower 55 project. Put another way, various influential bodies and council members would like to take the streetcar study money and instead turn it over to helping BNSF and Union Pacific, the two railroad companies impacted by the Tower 55 situation. (This is not for anything related to the Tower 55 trenches being discussed – this is for at-grade improvements to the existing north-south alignment.)
In addition, we hear talk of not wanting the streetcar to “compete” with other transit projects, as well as tons of misinformation about the streetcar project causing higher taxes or being paid for by raiding road repair funds, etc. – none of which are true.
This vote is to spend money the city has already been granted to hire HDR to conduct the right and proper study that needs to be done for the streetcar project. It doesn’t commit the city to building anything. Whether we decide in the end to build the streetcar or not, this study needs to be done. It will answer every question the council could have about the project, and probably then some. We feel that it would be incredibly irresponsible and careless to kill the study before the city has all the facts. The council shouldn’t say “no” before they know.
The decision to further delay the vote to hire HDR, Inc. to conduct the full design study – not even a vote to actually build the thing, just a vote to do the right and proper study that needs to be done, whatever the eventual outcome – showcases a staggering lack of leadership and forward-thinking on the part of this city government. After years of positive progress, much productive discussion, years of planning by talented individuals within our own committees, and a strong showing of support from the city government in a variety of venues (such as the Pacific Northwest fact-finding trip and the Tracks to the Future conference), to see that this Council seems to be back-pedaling under the cloud of incorrect information to raid the study grant to benefit two of the wealthiest corporations in America is extremely disappointing.
We have seen what effective multi-modal transit can do for a city, not only in terms of mobility but also in terms of development, livability, and the creation of truly remarkable places. We have seen that these sorts of places – higher density, with a variety of choices in living arrangement, transportation, employment, and recreation – foster some remarkable examples of creativity, prosperity, and life.
We have the opportunity, with this modern streetcar project, to help create those sorts of places in Fort Worth. It is clear that streetcars can attract far more riders than buses are capable of (due to an assortment of factors – comfort, smooth operation, ease of use, etc.). In addition, streetcars provide that “last couple of miles” connection from our commuter rail projects, leading to higher ridership overall. Getting more people on our transit systems means less congestion, better air quality, less dependence on increasingly unreliable supplies of fossil fuels, and the creation of far more successful and livable urban neighborhoods. Fort Worth’s current transit offerings are not sufficient if we are to truly create the city that we have been talking about. For example, Mayor Moncrief’s own words in the State of the City address, words he now seemed poised to flip-flop on:
Commuter Rail, street cars, and other alternative modes of transportation also remain a priority for me and this City Council. Unfortunately, Fort Worth and other major metropolitan areas are finding out the hard way what a mistake it was to design and build cities around automobiles years ago. Friends, we cannot continue to focus solely on building more roads for more vehicles. That’s counter productive at best. Business as usual is dead! North Texas requires a transportation overhaul. No more band-aides, no more patches—a complete overhaul!
If business as usual is truly dead, we must act to fully examine our transportation alternatives. Further delays, or an outright rejection, of the proposal to hire HDR to conduct our full streetcar study would be a grave mistake. To then raid that fund to benefit BNSF and UP would be an outrage.
Other cities obviously get it. Even Dallas is pulling further and further ahead of us in this regard, building off their ongoing DART light rail success with their own modern streetcar project – which defeated our own for TIGER funding at least in part due to the clear lack of leadership on the part of the Fort Worth city government and a muddled message coming from City Hall, in addition to the decision to submit only the downtown circulator without the Near Southside or Cultural District lines. Former Charlotte Mayor Pat McCrory, at the Tracks to the Future conference, spoke extensively of this need for strong leadership and a clear message.
These cities – cities like Dallas, and Portland, and Seattle, and Charlotte, and more – are more fully serving their citizens by creating real transportation choice. If Fort Worth continues to drop the ball on projects like the streetcar, we will lose out. These cities are competing with us for the jobs and vitality of the future, and we know that ever-increasing numbers of young creatives and professionals no longer wish to have the same suburban/car-dominated life that their parents and grandparents had. They want real choice, in living arrangement and transportation (and make no mistake, these two things are deeply linked – effective transit helps build effective mixed-use living arrangements, and vice versa). They will go where they can get these things, and if they can’t get them here, we’ll fall behind. If Fort Worth wants to compete on the global stage, we have to start getting serious about this sort of thing. It is time Fort Worth stopped wishing to remain a “small town” forever and started acting like the proud, vibrant, major American city it is.
Our current transit infrastructure (especially The T’s woefully poor bus projects) are not enough to compete on the national and international stage.
We must get serious, and we must give this study its due as we do with every other major decision. This city has the opportunity to work with the finest transit minds in the United States to come up with solutions that work for us. This is perhaps one of the most important proposals to come before the City Council, ever – it deserves the same level of attention as our other major decisions. This is not a vote to fund the entire system – it is a vote to make a relatively miniscule investment to find out all the facts we need before we make further decisions to proceed. There are valid concerns and questions about the streetcar project, but this City Council is behaving as though they don’t even want to answer them. The City Council wishes instead to bury its head in the sand and pretend that business as usual is, in fact, healthy and productive – when the evidence of the last several years shows that to be untrue. And it further wants to hand over the NCTCOG money to benefit two corporations for whom $1.8 million is chump change. Don’t be surprised, if this happens, that NCTCOG will be extremely reluctant to work with the city in the future as well as it has (and we wouldn’t be surprised, if we wind up cutting HDR loose after stringing them along, that Fort Worth’s reputation with transit planners and the Feds will be quite negatively impacted as well).
It bears repeating: don’t say “no” before we know. Whatever your stance on the streetcar project, it deserves full consideration as any other major decision does. There are questions that need answering and this is how we answer them, and the planners and money are already here and ready to go.
We see a growing resentment toward this City Council and a growing feeling that the City Council is making a last-minute, nonsensical course reversal after the years of planning, the consultant selection, and the vote to fund the study, not to mention this same City Council’s public expressions of support for this project. It seems like a dramatic failure of leadership, and a mess of petty political bickering. The fact that it happens behind closed doors in Fort Worth, rather than out in the open as in Dallas, doesn’t change the fact that it is terribly unfortunate and shameful.
We love Fort Worth. We also realize that it is not perfect, and that we are desperately behind in terms of transit. We know that people within City Hall know this to be true as well. If we drop the ball on this before even getting all the facts, it will be a black mark on our legacy.
We encourage all our readers to contact the City Council and express your concern and frustration with the delays and petty politics, and express your support for getting the study done with HDR. Here are their contact numbers and e-mail addresses:
Mayor – Mike Moncrief – 817-392-6118 – mike.moncrief@fortworthgov.org
Mayor Pro Tem – District 4 – Danny Scarth – 817-392-6187 – District4@fortworthgov.org
District 2 – Sal Espino – 817-392-8802 – District2@fortworthgov.org
District 3 – Zim Zimmerman – 817-392-8803 - District3@fortworthgov.org
District 5 – Frank Moss – 817-392-8805 – District5@fortworthgov.org
District 6 – Jungus Jordan – 817-392-8806 – District6@fortworthgov.org
District 7 – Carter Burdette – 817-392-8807 – District7@fortworthgov.org
District 8 – Kathleen Hicks – 817-392-8808 – District8@fortworthgov.org
District 9 – Joel Burns – 817-392-8809 – District9@fortworthgov.org
In addition, we are encouraging as many of our readers as possible to attend the City Council meeting on Tuesday, April 6th, at 7:00 PM, to show your support for the streetcar project. We are working with some of our associates to have T-shirts available at the meeting, as was done with the Bike Fort Worth plan. We’ll have more information this week, but for now, we hope you will try to be at the council meeting on the 6th to help support the project – and that you’ll tell your friends to help as well. We know the streetcar support is out there (in fact, we have numbers – more on that later), and now it’s time to tell your city representatives that we don’t want any more delays, or petty politics.
We are the new Fort Worth. We have the chance to move this city boldly into the future, just as our forefathers did when they brought the railroad to Fort Worth, just as Amon Carter did decades ago, and just as countless other great Fort Worthians have done since the days when this city was just an Army outpost on a bluff at the convergence of the West and Clear forks of the Trinity River. Make your voice heard.
EDIT: Had to add these comments from our friend at Walkable Dallas-Fort Worth:
Two key components. This is about real choice (which I harp on constantly) and economic development. Streetcars are what unlocked and created the neighborhoods immediately adjacent to downtowns, and crazy as it sounds, they are what will revitalize those same areas which have been decimated by speculation, zoning, and car-oriented policies and design.
EDIT: Here’s a link to a Fort Worth Weekly story by Dan McGraw about why we missed out on the TIGER grant. Of particular note is that our “downtown circulator” submission didn’t win because it didn’t go anywhere. Dallas was going to get laughed out of the US DOT offices as well with their original downtown-only plan. It was the better downtown-to-Oak Cliff plan that got them the money. That’s why we need to be focusing on a downtown-to-Near Southside or downtown-to-Cultural District starter plan.
EDIT: Here’s a letter of support from Fran McCarthy, chair of the Central City Redevelopment Committee.
Recent Comments