Apr 8, 2010 22
Revealed: Comerica Building, 8th & Magnolia
By: Kevin Buchanan
For the uninitiated, a building known as the Brace Building used to stand at 8th Avenue & Magnolia in the Near Southside. It was a two-story old mixed-use building that was in rather sad shape after years of neglect. In late 2008, Comerica Bank announced they were purchasing the building with the intent to demolish it and build a slightly-modified version of a typical Comerica bank branch, reoriented a bit to face the street and with a set of fake windows on top to make it look more old-fashioned. There was much debate about this plan from us, the nearby Fairmount neighborhood, and Fort Worth South, who has been championing multistory mixed-use infill on Magnolia.
Comerica took the Brace Building down in August of 2009, but agreed to go back to the drawing board on the design. Behind the scenes, Comerica agreed to hire a Near Southside local architect to come up with a more sensitive design for the site. Now, that design can be revealed.
The Comerica Building has been designed by the Near Southside’s own Quorum Architects (you may remember them from our profile of the firm). They have crafted an elegant, very urban structure to house the bank. Rather than the old plan of having fake “second floor” windows a la many new suburban “town square” buildings, the Comerica Building will be a full two stories tall. As a compromise from Comerica’s earlier “single story only” intent, when in use by Comerica, the building will not feature a functioning second floor, instead featuring a two-story-tall ceiling with lots of light from both levels of windows. However, the building has been design so that, should Comerica vacate the space, a functioning second floor can be added relatively easily in the upper space to create likely second floor residential units.
The building complies with the Near Southside urban design standards, is fully urban in form, and features a strong presence along both streets, as well as featuring a classic cut corner entrance. All parking is to the rear or on-street. In addition, the north facade facing the rear parking and bank drive-through has been designed to be as detailed as the street facades, creating an attractive appearance from further north along 8th as well. That rear parking/drive-through area is also heavily screened by a decorative fence and plantings to avoid impacting the pedestrian experience too much, and the drive-through shelter is designed in a matching style. Along Magnolia, the building features a wide, tree-lined brick sidewalk, and the corner features a large brick entry plaza-like space. The building also features extensive ground-floor windows to ensure transparency of the facade as prescribed by the Near Southside design standards.
We are frankly very surprised by how this building has turned out. Quorum has knocked this one out of the park in our opinion. Though the Brace Building is long gone now, this new building looks to hold down the important corner of 8th & Magnolia with a similar level of grace and is a fully urban structure with great compliance with the Near Southside urban design standards. The design strikes a good compromise between Comerica’s desire for a single-use structure and Fort Worth South’s desire for a mixed-use structure by being easily adaptable to mixed-use should the bank eventually leave, and in the meantime giving from the exterior a true two-story structure with real windows to help create the sense of enclosure by building facade that is key to an urban streetscape. Fort Worth South is recommending to the Urban Design Commission that the building be approved, and we think we have to join them in this recommendation. Kudos to Comerica for showing the willingness to create a far more appropriate structure for an urban setting, and to Quorum for what looks like an outstanding job of urban design.
For more views, click the thumbnails.
Edit: We couldn’t stand the thought of this great comment from Michael H. just hanging out in the comments, so here it is: Read the rest of this entry »























Recent Comments