McKee vs. Shlachter: Blogger vs. Startlegram

Forgive the diversion from our usual content, but this was too odd to pass up.

We consider ourselves to be fairly “hip” and “with it” people (NOTE: no actual quantity of hipness or with-it-osity is conferred with this sentence. Offer void in Utah), but we were surprised to learn of a butting-of-heads between a friend of ours and one of the folks at the Star-Telegram.

Fellow local blogger Robert McKee, whose DowntownFortWorth.com we also just noticed is back to life and looks pretty darned cool, runs a scavenger hunt on the site where contestants must match photos of each letter of the alphabet to the sign in Downtown Fort Worth that the letter appears on. As blogged about over on the Weekly, Robert had to delay announcing the winner of the most recent scavenger hunt due to his being in Scotland to put on a proper funeral ceremony for his father, who passed away a year prior.

Apparently, a delay in announcing the winner of a free contest on a web site so upset a participant, one Kevin McCambell, that he e-mail Robert several times to find out what the deal was. After a series of exchanges, Robert finally wrote back “I AM AT MY FATHER’S FREAKING FUNERAL,” and McCambell went on a crusade, complaining to the contest’s prize donors and to one Barry Shlachter, the Star-Telegram’s business writer.

Shlachter ran a story nit-picking Robert’s funeral story (choice quote: “scattering ashes in an Aloha shirt (he sent us a picture) may not be the same as a funeral (his father died in December), but why quibble?”). Being put on the defensive over what should be a harmless fun game and his providing closure for his father’s life understandably bothered Robert, and he demanded an apology from Shlachter.

He got a private apology from S-T editor Jim Witt, who said that the paper couldn’t give a public one. Unsatisfied, Robert decided to take things to the next step in getting an apology out of Shlachter, as also blogged about at the Weekly:

Well, an apology has not come (save for the two hilarious half-ass attempts to humor me by publishing the winner’s name in his column yesterday but ignoring the 900 pound gorilla) and therefore Wave II of Operation: Pepperspray has been launched. Observe: http://www.barryshlachter.com that’s right! Knowing he’s probably not savvy enough to have thought to secure it, I bought the domain of the mother-fucker’s name. And now, while he can print his stupid editorializing of peoples’ burial services, sit back with his tenure, and dismiss the whiny ‘letters-to-the-editor’ assuming people will just ‘move on,’ forever emblazoned on the internet, his name will be associated with his epic journalistic fail. At least until he apologizes in his column. Fucked with the wrong guy.

We wish Robert luck in getting an apology out of Mr. Shlachter. We can sympathize with him over the whole incident, at least to some extent – we know how the degree to which people (such as Mr. McCambell) can get very emotional, demanding, and downright rude over what is essentially a free, no-obligation-to-read-in-any-way web site can truly be bizarre.

Category: General

Tagged:

Responsible and thoughtful comments are welcome. Be aware, though, that this site exists in part as an advocacy site for New Urbanism and its potential to remake Fort Worth into an even more livable city than it is today. Thoughtful dissent is generally welcome insofar as it fosters thoughtful replies. Inflammatory dissent, whether intentional or not, will be deleted. Commenters whose comments we routinely delete will be banned. Nothing personal, but this is a privately owned and operated web site, and we are aiming for a specific tone and audience. Work within those guidelines and all will be well.

2 Responses

  1. lobster says:

    Kev — thanks for the kind words :D
    While I’ve received an unbelievable amount of support from people all over the country who have read about this on various websites, it’s nice to know someone out there is able to empathize with me on jackasses who make complaining about local blogs and websites their life’s passion. By not even finishing our lil’ contest and solely aiming to “rattle the cages” despite hearing I was out of the country on a trip to honor my deceased father, this guy indeed took it to a new level. ..Not only in sheer stupidity, but complete insensitivity.

    The fact that Mr. Shlachter took on this clod’s tip as a “business story” as if he was going to win some sort of Pulitzer Prize for investigative journalism is even more shocking, and his editorializing of a private family burial service made it repulsive. Despite this contest having run for eight years, somehow my short delay in posting results due to being overseas was enough for him to publicly imply there was something illegitimate or fraudulent going on. Maybe if I charged $50 to enter and then disappeared off the face of the Earth for three months, he’d have a story. A week delay in the results of a free contest and I get raked over the coals? Is this for real? And the funny part is that he made this assertion without ever looking at the contest itself, as he had twice mentioned that one must find *24* letters to win.

    It has been communicated to me that the FWST’s stance is that the readers have “moved on”. This may be, but I was personally defamed by this jerk’s reckless writing and I will continue to escalate my campaign to ensure they understand the gravity of this man’s erroneous and unprofessional choice of words.
    ;)

  2. Haretip says:

    Wow. I got my popcorn. Looking forward to learning what escalation means.

    Nice way to look a gift horse in the mouth. Hope Lobs doesn’t quit organizing the hunt on account of one jackass. As for Schlachter, I’ve been looking for a reason to use the word “douchebaggery” all day long. Is it in the dictionery yet?

Advertisements