Fort Worthology goes to Portland, Part One: Transit

And now, the beginning of a series of posts detailing our recent exploratory trip to Portland, Oregon – it’s Part One of “Fort Worthology goes to Portland.”

In today’s installment, we’ll be taking a look at Portland’s transit systems, including the much-talked-about Portland Streetcar.

We’ve been big supporters of the Fort Worth Streetcar proposal since Day One, and now having spent over a week living with the system that serves as a model for our own plan, we are pleased to be able to type the following sentence from first-hand experience:

The Portland Streetcar is awesome.

It doesn’t really quite hit until you’ve spent time around a modern streetcar just how much it has defined and shaped the built environment. The Portland Streetcar has helped enable the creation of some incredible, incredible places. It serves as a popular and reliable circulator and “pedestrian accelerator,” attracting a diverse range of riders crossing socioeconomic barriers. It ties Downtown Portland and its Portland State University district, the Pearl District, the Northwest/Nob Hill neighborhoods, Riverplace, and the South Waterfront/OHSU neighborhoods into one pretty cohesive urban space. It extends the practical walking distance across a good majority of the central city.

Developments and neighborhoods come to be defined at least in part by their streetcar proximity. Businesses feature it on their logos. Diners feature “streetcar specials” for riders getting off in front of their establishments. It becomes tightly knit into the very fabric of the neighborhoods it passes through in a way that no bus ever has or could. Streetcars are about mobility, yes, and development – but no less real is their incredible power in placemaking.

First, the basics. The Portland Streetcar currently runs on a circulator loop through urban Portland on the west side of the Willamette river. I say “currently” because an extension to the east side of the Willamette has just been approved which will radically increase the system’s reach, but construction has not yet started on that new segment.

At its northernmost, the streetcar runs from the Northwest district into the Pearl District, a former industrial expanse that is now one of the most impressive urban districts in the entire United States. Turning south in the Pearl, the streetcar then passes into Downtown Portland, and then into the heart of Portland State University. It passes from there through the Riverplace district into the new South Waterfront district, another impressive infill project on former industrial land.

Along the way, the streetcar allows easy transfers to TriMet buses, the MAX light rail system, and the Portland Aerial Tram.

Streetcar stops are simple affairs – a wide sidewalk, a slight raise in height to meet the streetcar’s floor, a shelter and a sign. They’re not that different from a bus stop – in fact, some streetcar stops are shared with bus lines.

The streetcars run roughly every 12-15 minutes at each stop (though as seen above, sometimes it’s more often), giving frequent service and helping to attract more riders. One of the most impressive bits about the stops are these, the real-time arrival information signs. Each streetcar has GPS and this information is piped to stops to show exactly when each streetcar will be arriving. From our experience, the times shown on the stop are bang-on accurate.

What’s also extremely cool is the real-time arrival map which allows riders to see exactly where each streetcar is on the network. Hovering your mouse over each streetcar allows you to see what its next stop is, and hovering over each stop shows the approximate time until the next streetcar arrives. It’s all a part of making transit more efficient and easy to use, which in turn increases ridership.

The Portland Streetcar uses these Skoda-Inekon cars made in Europe. They are comfortable, smooth, fast to accelerate, fully climate-controlled, and extremely quiet in operation. The only real noise during operation is a high, quiet whirring/whistle as their electric motors sing them along the tracks. In terms of ridership experience, they are nothing at all like either buses or even vintage streetcar systems like the Dallas McKinney Avenue line. They are the very definition of sleek, modern transportation.

Now, there’s even a group in Oregon building American-made streetcars for the system off the Skoda-Inekon design: United Streetcar

On-board, the streetcars are simple and easy to use. The front and rear cars have higher floors and many seats, along with rails and straps for standing. The middle segments have low floors for easy boarding, including physically challenged riders, with fewer seats and more standing room.

If you don’t already have a TriMet pass, passes can be purchased on-board the streetcar using these simple fare boxes.

Riding a modern streetcar is very comfortable and pleasant. There’s none of the lurching and bouncing of a bus – it really does glide quite smoothly over the rails.

The streetcar operates in mixed traffic with cars on most of its route. Despite some naysayers who blast the streetcar for “getting bogged down” in traffic, in practice this was not our experience. In riding the streetcar extensively during all hours of the day, we never experienced a delay of more than a few seconds – nearly always due to, say, somebody opening a door for too long on a parked car on the street side. A quick ring of the streetcar’s bell or blast of its horn cleared these up and we were quickly back on the way.

It’s certainly possible for traffic to impact a streetcar, just like a bus – but in practice, these instances seem pretty rare.

The streetcars integrate perfectly into the urban environment. Even though they’re longer than a bus, they still feel right at home in tight spaces. The overhead wires simply aren’t an issue, in terms of aesthetics – here, we’re seeing as many wires as you will ever seen on a streetscape, as the streetcar crosses the MAX light rail line here. The wires are negligible in their impact on the scenery.

Even in crowds, the streetcar operates well. Pedestrians feel comfortable walking around it, even in motion, as its tracks create predictable travel paths. In many places in Portland, the streetcar runs right past sidewalk cafes, and in fact in Portland State University it runs right through a pedestrian plaza in the center of campus. It passes no more than a few feet from a popular outdoor cafe on the college plaza, and never disturbs diners.

Here, a typical scene at a busy streetcar stop, showing the volume and range of riders and the simple stop setup.

Here, a streetcar headed into Downtown Portland passes by one headed to the South Waterfront. Seen on the sides of streetcars and at stops, a variety of advertising & sponsorship opportunities provide another example of business/streetcar integration. Sponsored stops are announced as such.

Much has been written about the development around the streetcar line, and “impressive” doesn’t begin to describe it. The Pearl District alone is a sea of extremely impressive development, both in adaptive re-use of historic buildings and in new construction. The streetcar has helped shape this development by encouraging an active streetscape, increased pedestrian activity, and by allowing developers to build far higher density and far less parking than would otherwise have been feasible. Without nearly as much parking to worry about paying for, developers can concentrate more on design, detailing, finishes, retail, and other aspects of their developments. Along the streetcar, you simply do not see the kind of massive parking garages common in infill here in Texas, such as those along West 7th Street. Here, the streetcar passes a former armory turned live stage theater.

Here, the streetcar passes a large residential building with ground-floor retail in the “Brewery Blocks” segment of the Pearl.

The streetcar in the Pearl. New infill can be seen rising in the background.

More Pearl District streetcar line infill.

More streetcar infill. The streetcar also stops at both of the Pearl’s major public spaces – here, we’re at Jamison Square (on the right).

Still more Pearl District streetcar infill. If you think the West 7th projects here in Fort Worth are impressive, the Pearl is on an entirely other level – and they’re lacking the huge parking structures that have accompanied the West 7th projects. The Pearl is block after block after block of extremely high-quality infill – far larger than the West 7th projects.

Here, more Pearl streetcar infill – including the famed “Streetcar Lofts” with accompanying neon sign.

Still more huge infill along the streetcar line, this time near Tanner Springs Park.

Everywhere you turn in the Pearl, you see block after block of attractive infill along the streetcar line, and bleeding into the blocks surrounding the line as well. Because Portland has very small 200′ by 200′ blocks, just like those in Downtown Fort Worth, walking a few blocks to catch the streetcar is seen as perfectly normal.

Still more streetcar infill in the Pearl, this time around Tanner Springs Park, the other major public space in the Pearl. We’ll be talking more specifically about Portland’s architecture and parks/plazas in later posts.

And still more streetcar infill around Tanner Springs Park.

Even more streetcar infill in the Pearl. The feel as one moves through the Pearl is of a more European than American city in some ways.

And – why not – some more streetcar infill in the Pearl.

And still more. This building was especially impressive – a very Streamline Moderne industrial feel, but built in 2000.

And more – this building was just about to open.

Some adaptive reuse of historic structures nearby.

And more.

And more – these are townhomes in an old building, right on the line.

More Pearl infill – and yes, that’s a Whole Foods.

Also right on the line, this incredibly impressive Safeway.

We could go on, but we’ll talk more about the Pearl’s architecture and Portland’s awesome urban grocery stores in other posts.

Another major infill development on the streetcar line is the South Waterfront, at the current southern terminus of the circulator loop. Here, formerly abandoned industrial land is being reclaimed as a dense neighborhood of residential, office, and retail space, and the streetcar links to OHSU via the Portland Aerial Tram.

More South Waterfront streetcar infill.

Still more of this epic infill project.

Still more transit operating in Portland are the MAX light rail lines. These are Portland’s equivalent of the Dallas DART light rail trains, in that they make stops in the city center but also run on dedicated right-of-way to outlying areas in more of a commuting fashion, like Beaverton, Gresham, and Portland International Airport. It’s a good example of rail transit covering the whole spectrum – MAX providing longer-distance trips and linking with the streetcar for the “last mile” connections.

TriMet passes work on MAX, buses, the streetcar, the WES commuter train (which we did not have a chance to see), and the Portland Aerial Tram, allowing seamless transfers between modes.

Here, MAX passes through the Old Town district of Downtown Portland.

And here, it passes through Downtown on its way to the Goose Hollow neighborhood.

Another transit system in Portland, and by far one of the most unique, is the Portland Aerial Tram, linking the Streetcar and South Waterfront with the OHSU campus on a hill high above the waterfront. The tram runs constantly through the day, ferrying workers and students up and down from the campus to a lower office building & cafe in the South Waterfront and an adjacent streetcar stop & major bike commuter parking area. The trip takes about three minutes each direction.

The aerial tram uses two of these futuristic silver pods running back and forth along cables between the South Waterfront and OHSU.

Here, we pass a South Waterfront-bound tram on our way to OHSU.

Looking up at the OHSU tram station from inside the pod.

The tram gives some truly spectacular views of the surrounding neighborhoods.

Entering OHSU station.

The tram takes on passengers at OHSU station.

Preparing to depart from OHSU to head back to South Waterfront.

The view from OHSU station – on a clearer day with a view of Mt. Hood, it would be even more spectacular.

South Waterfront from OHSU station.

The pod departs OHSU, while the other pod starts its climb back up the hill.

On-board the pod headed back to OHSU.

The view of Downtown from the pod.

Arriving back at South Waterfront station.

The pod heads back to OHSU.

The pod passes the system’s support tower.

Transit in Portland is extremely easy and efficient. It is not only possible to live car-free there, but downright pleasant to do so. When one combines the streetcar, MAX, the tram, and TriMet’s extensive bus network (many of which run every 12-15 minutes like the streetcar, in contrast to The T’s 30-minute to 1-hour scheduling so often seen here in Fort Worth) with a bicycle, one can get around very easily indeed.

We were particularly impressed with the Portland Streetcar, and it gives us even more enthusiasm to get our system built. The streetcar helped revitalize several areas of central Portland, and has become a tightly-knit part of life for residents as well as visitors. Often times the streetcars were standing-room-only, a testament to their ease of use and attractiveness to riders. The sheer amount and quality of infill seen along the line was very impressive.

This is our initial post in our series on Portland. In future posts, we’ll talk about:

Bicycling
Parks & Plazas
Architecture
Residential Development
Local Businesses
The retail scene in urban Portland
The brewpub culture
The vegan/vegetarian culture
The Ira Keller Fountain, a beautifully restored plaza space designed by Lawrence Halprin, in stark contrast to our own decaying Halprin space, Heritage Park
Food Carts (seriously)

And more. We will, of course, post about Fort Worth stuff at the same time, but looking at other cities which serve as models for our own development can be helpful in learning about techniques that can work here in Fort Worth as we urbanize. So, there’s more Portland to come.

Category: Architecture & Urban Design, Transit & Infrastructure

Tagged: , , , , , ,

Responsible and thoughtful comments are welcome. Be aware, though, that this site exists in part as an advocacy site for New Urbanism and its potential to remake Fort Worth into an even more livable city than it is today. Thoughtful dissent is generally welcome insofar as it fosters thoughtful replies. Inflammatory dissent, whether intentional or not, will be deleted. Commenters whose comments we routinely delete will be banned. Nothing personal, but this is a privately owned and operated web site, and we are aiming for a specific tone and audience. Work within those guidelines and all will be well.

22 Responses

  1. Steve says:

    Clearly George Will is right, Portland has sold out to the Commies and any other city would be insane to cite it an a worthy example of urban development. Mass transit is a high-faloutin’ Liberal pipe dream! ;)

  2. Dave says:

    Living with all of this everyday, I sometimes forget how unusual it is in the US. I bike to work at OHSU every day (as well as most of my other trips around the city), and use the aerial tram (I wonder if I saw you) and have used the bus and streetcar systems extensively for years. It really is easy to get around Portland, and though it has some definite kinks to get out, and some need for political will in terms of limiting automobiles, certainly we could be in a much worse situation :)

    I’m really excited about the eastside extension of the streetcar – I think slow-but-faster-than-walking transportation options are really important for cities. We’re a bit too obsessed with speed, and we don’t realize that creating infrastructure where we can go 35-40 mph in-between frequent stop signals doesn’t move traffic much/any faster, and creates more frustration than traffic that flows smoothly at 15mph.

    In your list of things, you forgot the coffee culture :)

  3. Dave,

    Thanks for reminding me! Coffee is actually something I do want to talk about, as the coffee we had in Portland apparently came from a parallel universe from that which we have here in Texas. So smooth and flavorful, no bitterness, served more often than not at a drinkable temperature – it was greatness. We’ll definitely talk about it in a post.

  4. Steve,

    Clearly. :) Actually, I just saw on Streetsblog that Rep. Earl Blumenauer issued a challenge to Will to come to the northwest and debate him:

    “In his article, Mr. Will proves that he is mired in a one-dimensional past, one that the city of Portland has successfully overcome” said Blumenauer. “He opposes policies that will provide Americans with more choices while saving them money, creating jobs and protecting the environment. In Portland we have been able to increase productivity, boost our economy, and invest in our city’s resources by taking a well-rounded approach to transportation. Secretary LaHood shares this comprehensive view on transportation options for our nation — it’s not about behavior modification its about giving Americans the freedom to choose more than just the highway or byway.

    Rather than pontificate about practicality from afar, I challenge Mr. Will to come experience Portland, and then debate the facts, the future and the visions we offer,” continued Blumenauer. “I am proud to defend the Portland model so painstakingly developed and implemented over the last 1/3 of a century. Maybe he will understand why young well educated people move here without jobs and older, well established business and professional people won’t leave for jobs that pay more. We will be happy to buy his plane ticket and give him a bottle of Oregon pinot to die for.”

  5. Dave,

    Also, thanks for your local perspective. I would imagine that all this is old hat to you, but to us, visiting Portland was a wake-up call. I am proud of what Fort Worth has done thus far but it is clear we have a lot left to do – which is why we’re glad to be here, giving examples of what other places have accomplished.

  6. Dave says:

    I think another thing that might be interesting to note about Portland is urban agriculture – the city is planning education to encourage people to grow food for themselves at their place of residence, they are planning 1300 new community garden plots (in addition to the fairly numerous ones that exist already in parts of inner Portland), and they allow things like raising chickens within city limits at your place of residence. You might be planning to mention this in your urban grocery store post too, but there are also a lot of grocery stores, co-ops and farmers markets that make it really easy to get produce, meat, etc grown in or near Portland as well.

    If you have any specific questions or things I can clarify, just let me know.

    It’s great to see more and more people around the country paying attention to this stuff, and it’s nice to think we might be a resource for other places that want to change their cities. Cheers!

  7. M1EK says:

    The traffic-down-boggery is limited because they started, first, with a strong and extensive LRT service which has reduced automobile traffic in the core of their downtown compared to cities of similar size (Ft. Worth, Austin).

  8. M1EK,

    Was wondering when you’d come by. :)

    Even during times of traffic, I never saw the streetcar get bogged down at all. And I’d like to invite you to Fort Worth to see where, exactly, on the proposed streetcar routes there is traffic anywhere near bad enough to really negatively affect the streetcar – because I’m not seeing it.

    Dedicated ROW light rail is a great thing, and it has many great uses. I’ve never been against it, and in fact am a big supporter of it as you should know. But the streetcar is a great thing as well and has many great uses, too – a dedicated right-of-way isn’t the be-all-end-all. They (streetcars and light rail) serve two very different purposes, after all. They aren’t rapid transit and shouldn’t be judged by the same sort of mindset as a higher-speed light rail line.

    And if your counter is to be “buses can do what streetcars do, only better because they’re not fixed,” well, all I can say is, I’ve *never* seen a bus that could so impressively attract riders and affect the built environment like a streetcar. Buses are needed, too – but they can’t be the sole mode of neighborhood transit. The streetcar makes places – buses do not.

    (And lest you forget, we are also increasing our heavier rail systems via the SW2NE line that the T is planning. It all ties together.)

  9. Dave says:

    Oh, the one other thing I forgot to mention about the streetcar, is that it makes a great place to ride a bike, where it’s allowed, because not nearly as many people drive in the streetcar lanes, and the lane for the streetcar is completely flush with the rest of the road. Just be careful crossing them if you have skinny tires (I’ve never had a problem).

  10. Neil says:

    Great work! Very extensive. You know, you are a real asset to this community. Thanks for all you do!

  11. Binx says:

    The George Will column: http://www.newsweek.com/id/197925

    The Matt Yglesias response: http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/archives/2009/05/george-wills-irritable-mental-gestures.php

    The census bureau stats are pretty damning.

    I don’t understanding how this is an ideological issue.

  12. Will says:

    Reminds me of Brussels, which was ridiculously easy to get around.

  13. Levan says:

    Another Portlander here. I study in Vancouver, which has an extensive and fantastic bus system, but I think you are right in that a bus line really doesn’t effect the areas around them in the same way business geared toward a streetcar can. Oh what I would give for a rail link between the downtown of that city the its university.

  14. Steph says:

    I wanted to bring the streetcar and the coffee home with me! And all the vegan restaurants. :-)

  15. Very cool. I was in San Francisco the week before you guys were in Portland, and I was pretty impressed with their system. We got around very cheaply and easily via bus the whole time (and one trip on the famous streetcar, but their Streetcar seems more like a useful tourist attraction than something the natives use). Our car never left the hotel parking lot. But Portland looks like it’s taken transit to a whole other level.

  16. Dan says:

    Meh…a complete waste of bandwidth. There’s not one mention of Portland’s greatest asset – beer! ;)

    You’ll have to visit some of the microbreweries on your next visit here. And I’ll be interested in your observations of bicycling in Portland. Glad you enjoyed our city, come back anytime.

  17. Wells says:

    As a Pearl District low-income resident and urban afficionado, I welcome visits from exotic American locales. Do all Texans wear cowboy hats and leash horses outside saloons? Just kidding. My last trip round yor parts I parked my sore butt on the Trinity Express and privately thanked President Lincoln for his foresight to imagine rail travel cross-country. Yee-doggies, to borrow the western colloquial saying, yew shore got sum nice country thereabouts, I tell you wut.

    There’s a lot can be learned from the Portland experience. Oregon had an uprisal in the 1970’s that made it so hard for Merikan developers to practice their creed, they done left and forgot Oregon. If Oregon grows in the forest, will a developer in California hear? Or, what is the sound of one streetcar rider clapping?

    The South Waterfront should be considered a ground-up master-planned community rather than infill, Kevin. The Pearl District is the better example of infill and the development model with the most potential until you research the regional development principle, which is off the charts, exponentially off the charts, and fundamental. If you have a good understanding of New Urbanism, think New Urbanism on steroids. So many jobs, so little time.

    You’re a good photographer. Don’t overhype Portland like it’s a cookie-cutter model. I’ve always figured Portland’s pedestrian infrastructure and parks are its essence. Transit users are first of all walkers. Good pedestrian access signals motorists to slow down. Portland still has a lot of traffic, but it’s so controlled, one doesn’t have to risk life and limb to cross the street. Celebrate the completion of several new Portland parks this year. They are sooooo ‘Economic’!!

  18. Patrick Major says:

    This post and the pictures make me want to pack up and move to portlnd.

  19. Douglas K says:

    Another Portland resident here. I found this post through portlandtransport.com.

    Glad you enjoyed your visit here. It’s pretty cool from a hometown pride perspective to see that kind of a glowing review from an outsider. Also just interesting to see how much I just take for granted from being around it all the time.

    The pictures were great. I gotta say, if I wasn’t here already, your write-up and photos would have me wanting to come visit.

    Looking forward to seeing the rest of your impressions of Portland. (BTW, Dan: one of them is going to be about the brewpub culture.)

  20. Mary Sue says:

    I was cursing the Streetcar on my way in to work this morning for being slow and poky, because WOE it took me 15 minutes to go two miles!

    Thanks for reminding me that it’s actually pretty awesome. I’m starting to get jaded as I begin my fourth year in PDX.

    Regarding the South Waterfront, I do want to heartily disagree. I’ve been working down here for close to four years, watching the condos go up around my little warehouse. It was not, and is not, abandoned industrial land. There were quite a number of companies that were located down here that were moved out as the condos came in.

    Although I do have to say, it’s nice having several options to walk to lunch, instead of just the Old Spaghetti Factory.

    I really do hope that in your visit you got out of the West Side, though. East Side for the WIN!

  21. Gabriel says:

    As a Portlander, I love our transit system. I’ve never driven a car in my life, and so long as I live in Portland I hope I never have to.

  22. Dave Hogan says:

    Another Portlander here, and you did a great write-up on our little city.

    I moved here three years ago from San Diego, appreciating the transit but not thinking that I really needed it. I used the buses and trolley in San Diego sometimes, but still pretty much had to drive to get to a lot of places.

    Over the next two and a half years I realized that the only time I used my car was to get to work in Vancouver (our neighbor in Washington State to the north.) On weekends and evenings, I was taking a bus or the streetcar everywhere, and the city’s small enough taking a cab back isn’t cost-prohibitive.

    When my car was stolen and I left that job three months ago, I decided not to buy another one, and I haven’t missed it more than once. In that case I realized getting a grill onto a bus might be a problem, but a helpful friend offered a ride. I would have used a ZipCar (car sharing) otherwise, so it really wasn’t a big deal.

    The buses and streetcar might not be high speed transit, but it’s usually not that bad even to go clear across the city since the buses run frequently, and you’re not stuck waiting 20-30 minutes for a transfer. It works well enough for me.

    I’m definitely excited to see the rest of the articles. Great pictures and writeup, you seem to have really captured the Pearl well.

Advertisments