UPDATE: Actually, an update/clarification. It’s my understanding that the council has, indeed, continued the vote, meaning it’ll be put off until another council meeting. This still doesn’t help our standing with the FTA.
Additionally, I’ve received word from sources close to the situation that Mayor Moncrief and Councilman Jungus Jordan were, in fact, intending to kill the resolution completely. It looks like it was Councilman Joel Burns who was able to get the continuance instead of the outright defeat. So, while it’s not exactly in a healthy condition, the resolution’s not dead – thanks to Burns, it’s at least still on life support. Thank Councilman Burns the next time you see him.
———-
UPDATE 2: Some words from the council members and the mayor prior to the vote. These are all paraphrased:
Carter Burdette: Doesn’t want to express any support without the HDR study. (My opinion: wants to kill it through endless studies.) Made some reference to developers and, if I’m not mistaken, Councilman Burns (didn’t say Joel outright, but it was obvious and weird) for “pushing” streetcar system (so, numerous studies in one form or another since the ’70s is “pushing,” now, apparently).
Jungus Jordan: Says he supports better circulation, but seems to be wanting to just do more buses. Highlights “natural gas powered” buses – of course. Wants to withdraw resolution, says we were “premature” in asking for it.
Sal Espino: Supports streetcar. Feels we can’t keep building more and more concrete to solve our development and traffic problems.
Danny Scarth: Says more roads, along with traffic light timing, will solve our traffic problems. (Because putting more cars on the road always makes traffic better? Sigh.) Against resolution.
Zim Zimmerman is against, unsurprisingly. (Maybe if we could build a Bank of America branch in each streetcar, he’d come around?)
Kathleen Hicks: Generally positive, goes off on another of her rants about it being only in downtown (it’s not, and she should know that by now) and wanting it in her district (hey Kathleen, South Main is in your district!).
Frank Moss: We need to move forward with resolution. Streetcars are development catalysts, and we need to be encouraging for economy.
Joel Burns: Says NCTCOG has addressed all the concerns the council is feeling. We need to encourage development in the central city, which creates jobs and funding for things like libraries and pools. We must send strong message to FTA thanking them for the grant.
Mayor Moncrief: Blames himself for encouraging streetcar, says Tower 55 is top priority (good grief), after than commuter rail, and after that streetcar. Moves to table the resolution, says Tower 55 must come first.
Motion is passed, resolution is tabled.
———-
At the City Council meeting this morning at 10:00 AM, a resolution will be put before the council on the subject of the modern streetcar project and other rail projects. Various planners and officials have repeatedly stressed that we have a “three-legged stool” of rail projects of equal importance – Tower 55, SW2NE commuter rail, and the streetcar. The resolution reads as follows:
A RESOLUTION REAFFIRMING SUPPORT FOR TOWER 55 AT-GRADE IMPROVEMENTS, SOUTHWEST-TO-NORTHEAST COMMUTER RAIL, AND A MODERN STREETCAR SYSTEM, AND IDENTIFYING NON-COMPETING FUNDING SOURCES FOR SAID PROJECTS
WHEREAS on March 9, 2010, the City Council approved Resolution No. 3867 adopting the City of Fort Worth’s Amended 2010 Federal Legislative Program, which expressed support for funding for Tower 55 at-grade improvements, Southwest-to-Northeast commuter rail, and a modern streetcar system; and
WHEREAS the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) has awarded $24.99 million in Urban Circulator grant funds for a modern streetcar starter project in Fort Worth; and
WHEREAS the FTA is seeking clarification on the City’s commitment to the modern streetcar project and its ability to provide the local match; and
WHEREAS the Mayor’s Rail Funding Strategies Committee has identified non-competing funding sources for the three important rail projects (Exhibit A); and
WHEREAS the Mayor’s Rail Funding Strategies Committee has recommended the allocation of $1 million for Tower 55 at-grade improvements; and
WHEREAS City of Fort Worth staff has determined that existing tax increment finance (TIF) districts will generate sufficient revenue to provide local matching funds for the FTA grant in a manner that will result in no competition for federal, state, or local funding among the City’s high-priority rail projects; and
WHEREAS the Fort Worth Transportation Authority has committed up to $2 million per year for the annual operating costs of a modern streetcar starter project and is capable of operating a modern streetcar system; and
WHEREAS the City Council will receive a business plan for a modern streetcar starter project in November 2010 from HDR Engineering, Inc. and the Modern Streetcar Task Force, as communicated to FTA in May 2010;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FORT WORTH THAT:
The City of Fort Worth reaffirms its support for Tower 55 at-grade improvements, Southwest-to-Northeast commuter rail, and a modern streetcar system; and
The City of Fort Worth intends to consider certain non-competing funding sources for these rail projects, as set forth in Exhibit A; and
The City of Fort Worth pledges $1 million in certificates of obligation for Tower 55 at-grade improvements in connection with the Texas Department of Transportation application for federal TIGER II Discretionary Grant funds; and
Upon receipt of an acceptable business plan in November 2010, the City of Fort Worth will seek to secure TIF funds as local match for the FTA Urban Circulator grant for a modern streetcar starter project that provides Downtown circulation and connectivity between the Intermodal Transportation Center, employment centers and nearby mixed-use urban neighborhoods.
In essence, saying that Tower 55, SW2NE, and the streetcar are all very important projects, and with non-competing funding sources for all projects identified and pending the arrival of a workable business plan from HDR for the modern streetcar, the city will then seek to get funds from the various TIF districts involved to move ahead with the modern streetcar project. This resolution is important, because due to the city’s waffling on the project since the Federal Transit Administration awarded Fort Worth a grant for $25 million for the streetcar, the FTA has been wanting clarification of the city’s stance towards the project. FTA wants real projects that expect to turn dirt.
Without this resolution, it’s quite likely the FTA may wind up pulling the $25 million grant from Fort Worth, harming not only the streetcar project but our interactions with federal transportation officials for other projects as well.
My take is that the council itself is likely to be split 4-4, with Joel Burns, Kathleen Hicks, Sal Espino, and Frank Moss voting for the resolution, and Jungus Jordan, Zim Zimmerman, Carter Burdette, and Danny Scarth voting against it, making Mayor Moncrief’s vote crucial one way or another. Moncrief has been waffling, and this morning it appears likely that he will vote against the resolution as well, harming the streetcar project he has been a supporter of thus far as well as putting other transportation projects seeking federal dollars into harm’s way. See update above.
The resolution isn’t tying Fort Worth’s hands – it’s something to keep the FTA happy so that we can get our study finished with HDR and then, pending a workable business plan from HDR, then decide to move forward on the streetcar project with access to the important $25 million grant. To vote against this resolution, despite the fact that the streetcar doesn’t compete with Tower 55 or SW2NE Rail, strikes me as extremely short-sighted of the city government. In my opinion, there have been some very real efforts from a small group of powerful folks to confuse the streetcar funding issue and kill the project at any cost, and this strikes me as the latest effort in that game.
Streetcar supporters are urged to head to the 10:00 AM council meeting and fill out speaker cards to voice their support for the resolution and the project. It also wouldn’t hurt to contact Mayor Moncrief:
Mayor – Mike Moncrief – 817-392-6118 –mike.moncrief@fortworthgov.org
Or, for that matter, the council:
Mayor Pro Tem – District 4 – Danny Scarth – 817-392-6187 –District4@fortworthgov.org
District 2 – Sal Espino – 817-392-8802 –District2@fortworthgov.org
District 3 – Zim Zimmerman – 817-392-8803 -District3@fortworthgov.org
District 5 – Frank Moss – 817-392-8805 –District5@fortworthgov.org
District 6 – Jungus Jordan – 817-392-8806 –District6@fortworthgov.org
District 7 – Carter Burdette – 817-392-8807 –District7@fortworthgov.org
District 8 – Kathleen Hicks – 817-392-8808 –District8@fortworthgov.org
District 9 – Joel Burns – 817-392-8809 – District9@fortworthgov.org
Recent Comments